| Play Title | Theatre Group | Date Open |
|---|---|---|
| P.S., Your Cat is Dead | Conejo Afternoon Theatre | 1/1/82 |
| Paint Your Face on a Drowning in the River | Santa Paula Theatre Center | 11/1/88 |
| Paint Your Wagon | Firelight Dinner Theatre | 3/4/83 |
| Paint Your Wagon | Camarillo Community Theatre | 9/27/96 |
| Painting Churches | Plaza Players | |
| Painting Churches | Ensemble Theater | 12/12/93 |
| Pajama Game, The | Conejo Players | 3/29/85 |
| Passionella | Conejo Afternoon Theatre | 5/1/85 |
| Patio, The | Conejo Afternoon Theatre | 3/1/85 |
| Peacock Hill | Plaza Players | 1/29/92 |
| Peg O My Heart | Santa Paula Theatre Center | 5/1/89 |
| Peter Pan | Conejo Players | 11/2/84 |
| Peter Pan | Cabrillo Music Theatre | 6/16/95 |
| Peter Pan | Cabrillo Music Theatre | 7/26/02 |
| Peter Pan: The Musical | Simi Valley Arts | 5/7/05 |
| Pfeifer s People | Conejo Afternoon Theatre | 1/1/81 |
| Philadelphia, Here I Come | Conejo Players | 2/1/74 |
| Picasso at the Lapin Agile | Santa Paula Theatre Center | 4/25/03 |
| Picnic | Conejo Players | 2/7/75 |
| Pink Panther Strikes Again, The | Moorpark Melodrama | 6/16/95 |
| Pinocchio Visits the North Pole | Camarillo Community Theatre | 12/5/03 |
| Pipe Dream | Conejo Players | 4/3/81 |
| Pippin | Conejo Players | 4/5/80 |
| Pippin | Camarillo Community Theatre | 8/1/86 |
| Pirates of Penzance, The | Encore Dinner Theatre | 10/6/89 |
| Pirates of Penzance, The | Camarillo Community Theatre | 2/1/91 |
| Pirates of Penzance, The | Cabrillo Music Theatre | 7/23/99 |
| Pirates of Penzance, The | Moorpark Melodrama | 1/10/97 |
| Pirates of Penzance, The | Comedy Tonight Productions | 1/11/97 |
| Pirates of Penzance, The | Camarillo Community Theatre | 10/4/02 |
| Plain and Fancy | Conejo Players | 4/1/67 |
| Plain and Fancy | Actors' Rep Theatre of Simi | 2/1/99 |
| Play it Again, Sam | Camarillo Community Theatre | 3/8/00 |
| Play It Again, Sam | Vagabond Players | 1/17/03 |
| Playboy of the Western World | Conejo Players | 8/29/86 |
| Plaza Suite | Firelight Dinner Theatre | 1/1/81 |
| Plaza Suite | Conejo Players | 6/23/78 |
| Plaza Suite | Camarillo Community Theatre | 3/1/85 |
| Plaza Suite | Marquie Dinner Theatre | 5/15/92 |
| Plaza Suite | Vagabond Players | 4/19/02 |
| Pleasure of His Company, The | Stagedoor Theatre | 4/8/05 |
| Post Cards and Lemonade | Conejo Afternoon Theatre | 2/1/80 |
| Prelude to a Kiss | Plaza Players | 6/20/92 |
| Prelude to a Kiss | Elite Theatre Company | 6/18/04 |
| Price, The | Santa Paula Theatre Center | 3/13/94 |
| Prime of Miss Jean Brodie, The | Elite Theatre Company | 8/6/99 |
| Prisoner of Second Avenue | Conejo Players | 8/29/75 |
| Prisoner of Second Avenue | Marquie Dinner Theatre | 10/1/93 |
| Private Lives | Conejo Afternoon Theatre | 8/6/92 |
| Private Wars | Elite Theatre Company | 4/5/97 |
| Promises, Promises | Encore Dinner Theatre | 8/27/89 |
| Proof | Santa Paula Theatre Center | 9/10/04 |
| Proof | Ojai Art Center Theatre Co. | 6/25/04 |
| Pump Boys and Dinettes | Cabrillo Music Theatre | 4/18/97 |
| Pvt. Wars | Elite Theatre Company | 2/28/97 |
| Pygmalion | Conejo Players | 2/1/67 |